Rosternomics
DM

Douglas Melvin

Born Aug 8, 1952 · Chatham-Kent · age 73

Built playoff teams in Texas and Milwaukee, where trades for CC Sabathia and Zack Greinke pushed the small-market Brewers into October.

20 seasons with salary-era data across 2 stints. All figures are franchise-level outcomes during the tenure, not solely attributable to one executive.

Titles0
Pennants0
Playoffs5
Record1592–1629
Win %0.494
-12.6WAB — wins above budget126th/195 execs
+20.9Talent above budget — roster-construction alpha (talent your budget bought above expectation)39th/195 execs
1.33Acquisition leverage — playoff pts each bought win added, given the roster it joined (did you buy where wins matter?)61st/195 execs
-75.2WAR surplus (era-neutral, win-equiv)155th/195 execs
-98Roster surplus $M130th/195 execs

How the roster was sourced

Share of gross-positive acquired fWAR by channel (vs. league average).

Build channels — net fWAR

Acquired minus surrendered / signed minus walked.

Home-grown (draft/intl)+269.5
Trade+81.5
Free agency-84.8
Rule 5 / minor draft-0.3
Sourcing mix: 47% draft · 24% FA · 29% trade · 0% R5

Tenure breakdown

TeamRoleYearsSzns WAB WAB/yr TAB WAR surp HG Trade FA R5 AcqLev W-L% POPenWS Surp $M
Brewers GM 2003–2015 13 +6.7 +0.52 +33.6 +19.9 +196.6 +41.3 -31.2 -0.3 1.23 0.486 2 +26
Rangers GM 1995–2001 7 -19.3 -2.75 -12.7 -95.1 +72.9 +40.2 -53.6 +0.0 1.52 0.509 3 -124
Career total (1985+ data) 20 -12.6 +20.9 -75.2 +269.5 +81.5 -84.8 -0.3 1.33 0.494 5 -98

Players acquired — 300 players, by realized fWAR for the franchise (scroll for more)

PlayerPosTeam How Year fWAR
Ryan Braun OF MIL Draft 2005 +43.8
Jonathan Lucroy C MIL Draft 2007 +30.6
Alex Rodriguez 3B/SS TEX Free agency 2001 +27.0
Michael Young SS TEX Trade 2000 +25.0
Yovani Gallardo P MIL Draft 2004 +20.5
Rafael Palmeiro 1B TEX Free agency 1998 +19.9
Brandon Woodruff P MIL Draft 2014 +19.1
Rickie Weeks 2B MIL Draft 2003 +18.7
Freddy Peralta P MIL Trade 2015 +17.3
Mark Teixeira 1B TEX Draft 2001 +15.4
Colby Lewis P TEX Draft 1999 +14.3
C. J. Wilson P TEX Draft 2001 +11.5
Lorenzo Cain OF MIL Draft 2004 +9.7
Aaron Sele P TEX Trade 1997 +9.6
Hank Blalock 3B TEX Draft 1999 +9.3
Rick Helling P TEX Trade 1997 +9.3
Doug Davis P MIL Free agency 2003 +9.0
Chris Capuano P MIL Trade 2003 +8.9
Josh Hader P MIL Trade 2015 +8.8
Aramis Ramírez 3B MIL Free agency 2011 +8.4
Mike Cameron OF MIL Free agency 2008 +8.1
Kevin Mench OF TEX Draft 1999 +8.1
Devin Williams P MIL Draft 2013 +7.6
Zach Davies P MIL Trade 2015 +7.5
Jimmy Nelson P MIL Draft 2010 +7.2
Dave Bush P MIL Trade 2005 +7.0
Francisco Cordero P TEX Trade 1999 +7.0
Martín Maldonado C MIL Trade 2011 +6.3
Adrian Houser P MIL Trade 2015 +6.2
Ken Hill P TEX Free agency 1995 +5.6
Joaquín Benoit P TEX Intl FA 1996 +5.5
John Wetteland P TEX Free agency 1996 +5.4
Frank Catalanotto OF TEX Trade 1999 +5.0
Tyrone Taylor OF MIL Draft 2012 +4.9
Scooter Gennett 2B MIL Draft 2009 +4.7
Nori Aoki OF MIL Draft 2012 +4.6
Lyle Overbay 1B MIL Trade 2003 +4.5
Brent Suter P MIL Draft 2012 +4.5
Doug Davis P TEX Draft 1996 +4.4
Craig Counsell 2B/3B/SS MIL Free agency 2006 +4.3
Bobby Witt P TEX Trade 1995 +4.3
Shaun Marcum P MIL Trade 2010 +4.2
Khris Davis DH/OF MIL Draft 2009 +4.0
Matt Garza P MIL Free agency 2014 +3.9
Randy Wolf P MIL Free agency 2009 +3.7
Chris Narveson P MIL Free agency 2007 +3.6
Tim Crabtree P TEX Trade 1998 +3.5
Wily Peralta P MIL Intl FA 2005 +3.4
Lee Stevens 1B TEX Free agency 1996 +3.4
Jeff Zimmerman P TEX Draft 1999 +3.4
Nyjer Morgan OF MIL Trade 2011 +3.3
Mike Fiers P MIL Draft 2009 +3.2
Gabe Gross OF MIL Trade 2005 +3.2
Kyle Lohse P MIL Free agency 2013 +3.2
Bob Tewksbury P TEX Free agency 1995 +3.1
Damian Miller C MIL Free agency 2004 +2.7
Mickey Tettleton C TEX Free agency 1995 +2.5
Todd Zeile 3B TEX Trade 1998 +2.5
Francisco Cordero P MIL Trade 2006 +2.4
Hernán Pérez 2B/3B/OF MIL Free agency 2015 +2.4
Orlando Arcia SS MIL Intl FA 2010 +2.3
Jeff Suppan P MIL Free agency 2006 +2.3
Mike Venafro P TEX Draft 1995 +2.3
Víctor Santos P MIL Free agency 2003 +2.2
Luis Alicea 2B TEX Free agency 1997 +2.1
Jason Kendall C MIL Free agency 2007 +2.0
Adam Lind 1B/DH MIL Trade 2014 +2.0
Tyler Thornburg P MIL Draft 2010 +2.0
Matt Wise P MIL Free agency 2004 +2.0
Royce Clayton SS TEX Trade 1998 +1.9
Carlos Lee OF MIL Trade 2004 +1.8
Will Smith P MIL Trade 2013 +1.8
Carlos Villanueva P MIL Trade 2004 +1.8
Taylor Jungmann P MIL Draft 2011 +1.7
Gabe Kapler OF MIL Free agency 2007 +1.7
Kevin Elster SS TEX Free agency 1996 +1.7
Danny Kolb P MIL Free agency 2003 +1.6
Brian Shouse P MIL Trade 2006 +1.6
Bill Haselman C TEX Trade 1997 +1.6
Jacob Barnes P MIL Draft 2011 +1.5
Gabe Kapler OF TEX Trade 1999 +1.5
Wes Obermueller P MIL Trade 2003 +1.4
Russell Branyan 1B/3B MIL Free agency 2008 +1.3
Craig Counsell 2B/3B/SS MIL Trade 2003 +1.3
Zach Duke P MIL Free agency 2014 +1.3
Junior Spivey 2B MIL Trade 2003 +1.3
Gregg Zaun C MIL Free agency 2009 +1.3
Roberto Kelly OF TEX Free agency 1997 +1.3
Laynce Nix OF TEX Draft 2000 +1.3
Ed Vosberg P TEX Free agency 1995 +1.3
Rick Helling P MIL Free agency 2005 +1.2
Trevor Hoffman P MIL Free agency 2009 +1.2
John Vander Wal OF MIL Free agency 2003 +1.2
R. A. Dickey P TEX Draft 1996 +1.2
Mike Simms OF TEX Free agency 1996 +1.2
Kameron Loe P MIL Free agency 2009 +1.1
Mark Reynolds 1B/3B MIL Free agency 2014 +1.0
Alcides Escobar SS MIL Intl FA 2003 +0.9
Jim Henderson P MIL Trade 2012 +0.9
Tomo Ohka P MIL Trade 2005 +0.9
Mark Rogers P MIL Draft 2004 +0.9
Roger McDowell P TEX Free agency 1995 +0.9
Gary Glover P MIL Free agency 2004 +0.8
Tony Graffanino 2B MIL Trade 2006 +0.8
Jeremy Jeffress P MIL Draft 2006 +0.8
Brett Phillips OF MIL Trade 2015 +0.8
Damon Buford OF TEX Trade 1996 +0.8
Mark DiFelice P MIL Trade 2008 +0.7
Joe Dillon 2B/OF MIL Free agency 2007 +0.7
Trent Grisham OF MIL Draft 2015 +0.7
Juan Domínguez P TEX Intl FA 1999 +0.7
LaTroy Hawkins P MIL Free agency 2009 +0.6
Keith Osik C MIL Free agency 2003 +0.6
Francisco Rodríguez P MIL Free agency 2011 +0.6
Rob Wooten P MIL Draft 2008 +0.6
Jason McDonald OF TEX Free agency 2000 +0.6
Zach Braddock P MIL Draft 2005 +0.5
Tom Gorzelanny P MIL Free agency 2012 +0.5
Jason Rogers 1B MIL Draft 2010 +0.5
Julio Santana P MIL Free agency 2004 +0.5
Jason Botts DH/OF TEX Draft 1999 +0.5
Mike Morgan P TEX Free agency 1999 +0.5
Erasmo Ramirez P TEX Trade 2001 +0.5
Caleb Gindl OF MIL Draft 2007 +0.4
Eddie Pérez C MIL Free agency 2003 +0.4
Taylor Williams P MIL Draft 2013 +0.4
Scott Bailes P TEX Free agency 1996 +0.4
Mike Henneman P TEX Free agency 1995 +0.4
Mike Pagliarulo 3B TEX Free agency 1995 +0.4
Jorge De La Rosa P MIL Trade 2003 +0.3
José Veras P MIL Trade 2011 +0.3
Domingo Cedeño 2B/SS TEX Free agency 1997 +0.3
Gil Heredia P TEX Free agency 1996 +0.3
Xavier Hernandez P TEX Free agency 1996 +0.3
Mike Munoz P TEX Free agency 1999 +0.3
Warren Newson OF TEX Free agency 1995 +0.3
Yhonathan Barrios P MIL Trade 2015 +0.2
Tyler Cravy P MIL Draft 2009 +0.2
Jorge López P MIL Draft 2011 +0.2
Todd Ritchie P MIL Free agency 2003 +0.2
Takashi Saito P MIL Free agency 2011 +0.2
Milt Cuyler OF TEX Free agency 1998 +0.2
Lou Frazier OF TEX Trade 1995 +0.2
Eric Gunderson P TEX Free agency 1997 +0.2
Randy Knorr C TEX Free agency 2000 +0.2
Danny Kolb P TEX Draft 1995 +0.2
Craig Monroe OF TEX Draft 1995 +0.2
Brandon Boggs OF MIL Free agency 2010 +0.1
Frank Catalanotto OF MIL Free agency 2009 +0.1
Vinnie Chulk P MIL Free agency 2012 +0.1
Nelson Cruz DH/OF MIL Trade 2004 +0.1
Travis Ishikawa 1B MIL Free agency 2011 +0.1
Mark Kotsay OF MIL Free agency 2011 +0.1
Chris Magruder OF MIL Free agency 2003 +0.1
Mike McClendon P MIL Draft 2006 +0.1
Ariel Peña P MIL Trade 2012 +0.1
Terry Clark P TEX Free agency 1997 +0.1
Tom Evans 3B TEX Free agency 1999 +0.1
Ryan Glynn P TEX Draft 1995 +0.1
Darryl Hamilton OF TEX Free agency 1995 +0.1
Nick Masset P TEX Draft 2000 +0.1
Luis Ortiz 3B TEX Free agency 1996 +0.1
Jay Powell P TEX Free agency 2001 +0.1
Todd Van Poppel P TEX Free agency 1997 +0.1
Jason Bourgeois OF MIL Free agency 2008 +0.0
Dave Burba P MIL Free agency 2003 +0.0
Mike Burns P MIL Free agency 2009 +0.0
Carlos Corporán C MIL Draft 2003 +0.0
Kane Davis P MIL Free agency 2004 -0.0
Frankie De La Cruz P MIL Free agency 2011 +0.0
Matt Erickson 2B/SS MIL Trade 2004 +0.0
Sean Green P MIL Free agency 2010 +0.0
Tony Gwynn OF MIL Draft 2003 -0.0
Adrián Hernández P MIL Free agency 2004 -0.0
Zach Jackson P MIL Trade 2005 +0.0
Damien Magnifico P MIL Draft 2012 -0.0
Julio Mosquera C MIL Free agency 2005 -0.0
Nate Orf 2B/SS MIL Intl FA 2013 -0.0
Matt Pagnozzi C MIL Free agency 2013 -0.0
Tommy Phelps P MIL Free agency 2004 -0.0
Mike Rivera C MIL Free agency 2010 +0.0
Allan Simpson P MIL Free agency 2006 +0.0
Chris Spurling P MIL Free agency 2006 +0.0
Mel Stocker OF MIL Trade 2007 -0.0
Tyler Wagner P MIL Draft 2012 -0.0
Kevin Foster P TEX Free agency 2000 -0.0
Rosman García P TEX Trade 2001 +0.0
Shawn Hare OF TEX Free agency 1995 -0.0
Chris Howard P TEX Trade 1995 +0.0
Mike Hubbard C TEX Free agency 1998 -0.0
Travis Hughes P TEX Draft 1997 +0.0
A. J. Murray P TEX Draft 2000 +0.0
Chris Nichting P TEX Trade 1995 +0.0
John Rocker P TEX Trade 2001 -0.0
Rob Sasser PH/PR TEX Trade 1997 -0.0
J. D. Smart P TEX Free agency 2001 -0.0
Jack Voigt OF TEX Free agency 1996 +0.0
Edinson Vólquez P TEX Intl FA 2001 -0.0
Drew Anderson OF MIL Draft 2003 -0.1
Yuniesky Betancourt SS MIL Trade 2010 -0.1
Josh Butler P MIL Trade 2008 -0.1
Eric Farris 2B/OF MIL Draft 2007 -0.1
Jared Fernández P MIL Free agency 2005 -0.1
Mat Gamel 1B/3B MIL Draft 2005 -0.1
Sean Halton 1B MIL Draft 2009 -0.1
Mark Johnson C MIL Free agency 2003 -0.1
Justin Lehr P MIL Trade 2004 -0.1
Chris Mabeus P MIL Trade 2006 -0.1
Edwin Maysonet 2B/SS MIL Free agency 2010 -0.1
Travis Phelps P MIL Free agency 2003 -0.1
Josh Prince OF MIL Draft 2009 -0.1
Michael Reed OF MIL Draft 2011 -0.1
Vinny Rottino OF MIL Intl FA 2003 -0.1
Ángel Sálome PH/PR MIL Draft 2004 -0.1
Bryan Eversgerd P TEX Free agency 1997 -0.1
Travis Hafner DH TEX Draft 1996 -0.1
Billy Hatcher OF TEX Free agency 1995 -0.1
Sam Horn DH TEX Free agency 1995 -0.1
Jonathan Johnson P TEX Draft 1995 -0.1
John Marzano C TEX Free agency 1995 -0.1
Aaron Myette P TEX Trade 2000 -0.1
Matt Perisho P TEX Trade 1997 -0.1
Nick Regilio P TEX Draft 1999 -0.1
Brian Sikorski P TEX Trade 1999 -0.1
Kurt Stillwell SS TEX Free agency 1995 -0.1
Nevin Ashley C MIL Trade 2015 -0.2
Hiram Burgos P MIL Draft 2009 -0.2
Matt Clark 1B MIL Trade 2014 -0.2
Chris Demaria P MIL Trade 2005 -0.2
David Goforth P MIL Draft 2011 -0.2
Taylor Green 1B/3B MIL Draft 2005 -0.2
Jeff Liefer 1B/OF MIL Free agency 2004 -0.2
Braden Looper P MIL Free agency 2009 -0.2
Will Middlebrooks 3B MIL Free agency 2015 -0.2
Lyle Overbay 1B MIL Free agency 2014 -0.2
Jeremy Reed OF MIL Free agency 2011 -0.2
Mitch Stetter P MIL Draft 2003 -0.2
R. J. Swindle P MIL Free agency 2008 -0.2
Claudio Vargas P MIL Free agency 2009 -0.2
Joe Winkelsas P MIL Free agency 2006 -0.2
Justin Duchscherer P TEX Trade 2001 -0.2
Corey Lee P TEX Draft 1996 -0.2
Chris Magruder OF TEX Trade 2001 -0.2
Henry Mercedes C TEX Free agency 1996 -0.2
Juan Moreno P TEX Trade 2001 -0.2
Tanyon Sturtze P TEX Free agency 1996 -0.2
Anthony Telford P TEX Free agency 2001 -0.2
Pedro Valdés OF TEX Free agency 1999 -0.2
Chris Duffy OF MIL Free agency 2008 -0.3
Trent Durrington 2B MIL Free agency 2003 -0.3
Ben Ford P MIL Free agency 2003 -0.3
Jorge Julio P MIL Free agency 2008 -0.3
Juan Pérez P MIL Free agency 2011 -0.3
Logan Schafer OF MIL Draft 2008 -0.3
Adam Stern OF MIL Free agency 2009 -0.3
Omar Beltré P TEX Intl FA 2000 -0.3
Jeff Brantley P TEX Free agency 2001 -0.3
Mike Devereaux OF TEX Free agency 1997 -0.3
Rene Gonzales 2B/3B TEX Free agency 1996 -0.3
Scott Sheldon 3B/SS TEX Free agency 1997 -0.3
Scott Taylor P TEX Trade 1995 -0.3
B. J. Waszgis C TEX Trade 2000 -0.3
Chris Capuano P MIL Free agency 2008 -0.4
Wil Nieves C MIL Free agency 2010 -0.4
Laynce Nix OF MIL Trade 2006 -0.4
David Riske P MIL Free agency 2007 -0.4
Yadiel Rivera 3B/SS MIL Draft 2010 -0.4
Colin Walsh 3B MIL Rule 5 2015 -0.4
Jason Jones OF TEX Draft 1999 -0.4
Gary Bennett C MIL Free agency 2003 -0.5
Jeff Bennett P MIL Rule 5 2003 -0.5
Ricky Bottalico P MIL Free agency 2005 -0.5
Jake Elmore SS/OF MIL Free agency 2015 -0.5
Leo Estrella P MIL Free agency 2003 -0.5
Donovan Hand P MIL Draft 2007 -0.5
Blake Lalli C/1B MIL Free agency 2012 -0.5
Chris Smith P MIL Free agency 2008 -0.5
Mark Smith OF MIL Free agency 2003 -0.5
Wei-Chung Wang P MIL Draft 2014 -0.5
Juan Alvarez P TEX Free agency 2001 -0.5
Mark Clark P TEX Free agency 1998 -0.5
Alex Diaz OF TEX Free agency 1997 -0.5
Kelly Dransfeldt SS TEX Draft 1996 -0.5
Carlos Peña 1B TEX Draft 1998 -0.5
Alfredo Fígaro P MIL Free agency 2013 -0.6
Álex González SS MIL Free agency 2011 -0.6
Reynaldo Garcia P TEX Intl FA 1996 -0.6
Pat Mahomes P TEX Free agency 2001 -0.6
Erick Almonte SS MIL Free agency 2009 -0.7
Mike Gonzalez P MIL Free agency 2013 -0.7
Jeff Bianchi 3B/SS MIL Trade 2012 -0.8
Hideki Irabu P TEX Free agency 2001 -0.8
Éric Gagné P MIL Free agency 2007 -0.9
Johnny Hellweg P MIL Trade 2012 -0.9
Carl Everett OF TEX Trade 2001 -1.0
Ricky Ledée OF TEX Trade 2000 -1.0
Mike Lamb 1B/3B TEX Draft 1997 -1.3
Ramón Nivar OF TEX Intl FA 1998 -1.4
Yuniesky Betancourt SS MIL Free agency 2013 -1.8
Chad Moeller C MIL Trade 2003 -2.1

WAB = wins above what the team's payroll predicted (resource-controlled). WAR surplus = era-neutral value (WAR minus payroll in win-equivalents). Roster surplus $M = dollar value of WAR over cost. Build channels (realized fWAR): HG = home-grown via amateur draft / international signing; Trade = acquired minus surrendered (incl. purchases/waivers); FA = signed minus walked; R5 = Rule-5 / minor-league-draft pickups. Credit follows the acquisition year — home-grown to the regime at the player's draft/signing (not whoever was in the chair when he peaked), trade/FA/R5 to the GM who made the move. Players acquired as prospects before debuting (e.g. Smoltz, Bagwell; Rule-5 picks like Uggla) are counted as trade/R5, not home-grown. All are franchise-level outcomes during the stint, not solely attributable to one executive.