Rosternomics
JH

John Hart

Pioneered the long-term, cost-controlled contract extensions that turned the 1990s Cleveland Indians into a perennial AL power and two-time pennant winner, then ran the Rangers and Braves.

18 seasons with salary-era data across 3 stints. All figures are franchise-level outcomes during the tenure, not solely attributable to one executive.

Titles0
Pennants2
Playoffs6
Record1467–1379
Win %0.515
+31.9WAB — wins above budget27th/195 execs
+44.4Talent above budget — roster-construction alpha (talent your budget bought above expectation)21st/195 execs
1.43Acquisition leverage — playoff pts each bought win added, given the roster it joined (did you buy where wins matter?)48th/195 execs
-104.9WAR surplus (era-neutral, win-equiv)170th/195 execs
-224Roster surplus $M158th/195 execs

How the roster was sourced

Share of gross-positive acquired fWAR by channel (vs. league average).

Build channels — net fWAR

Acquired minus surrendered / signed minus walked.

Home-grown (draft/intl)+218.6
Trade-59.8
Free agency-50.2
Rule 5 / minor draft+8.2
Sourcing mix: 42% draft · 28% FA · 29% trade · 1% R5

Tenure breakdown

TeamRoleYearsSzns WAB WAB/yr TAB WAR surp HG Trade FA R5 AcqLev W-L% POPenWS Surp $M
Braves POBO/GM 2014–2017 4 -29.6 -7.39 -32.2 -29.7 +72.2 +28.8 +2.3 +1.7 0.39 0.442 -96
Rangers GM 2002–2005 4 -16.7 -4.17 -11.4 -47.3 +40.8 -16.9 -18.4 +6.5 0.71 0.480 -82
Guardians GM 1992–2001 10 +78.2 +7.82 +87.9 -27.9 +105.5 -71.7 -34.1 +0.0 1.92 0.561 62 -47
Career total (1985+ data) 18 +31.9 +44.4 -104.9 +218.6 -59.8 -50.2 +8.2 1.43 0.515 62 -224

Players acquired — 309 players, by realized fWAR for the franchise (scroll for more)

PlayerPosTeam How Year fWAR
Ronald Acuña OF ATL Intl FA 2014 +32.6
Ian Kinsler 2B TEX Draft 2003 +29.3
CC Sabathia P CLE Draft 1998 +28.0
Austin Riley 3B ATL Draft 2015 +20.6
Max Fried P ATL Trade 2014 +20.1
Roberto Alomar 2B CLE Free agency 1998 +18.9
Bartolo Colón P CLE Intl FA 1993 +16.9
Víctor Martínez C/DH CLE Intl FA 1996 +16.8
Dansby Swanson SS ATL Trade 2015 +16.1
Kenny Lofton OF CLE Free agency 1997 +14.8
Jake Westbrook P CLE Trade 2000 +13.5
Dave Burba P CLE Trade 1998 +11.7
Ender Inciarte OF ATL Trade 2015 +11.4
Tyler Flowers C ATL Free agency 2015 +10.6
Jhonny Peralta SS CLE Intl FA 1999 +10.1
David Justice OF CLE Trade 1997 +9.1
José Mesa P CLE Trade 1992 +9.1
Gary Matthews OF TEX Free agency 2004 +8.5
Dennis Martínez P CLE Free agency 1993 +8.4
Roberto Hernández P CLE Intl FA 2000 +8.3
Orel Hershiser P CLE Free agency 1995 +7.7
A. J. Minter P ATL Draft 2015 +7.0
Scott Feldman P TEX Draft 2003 +7.0
Chuck Finley P CLE Free agency 1999 +6.4
Alexi Ogando P TEX Rule 5 2005 +6.4
Paul Shuey P CLE Draft 1992 +6.3
Ellis Burks OF CLE Free agency 2000 +6.2
Mike Foltynewicz P ATL Trade 2015 +6.1
Milton Bradley OF CLE Trade 2001 +6.0
Eric Plunk P CLE Free agency 1992 +5.9
Nick Markakis OF ATL Free agency 2014 +5.8
Travis Fryman 3B CLE Trade 1997 +5.8
Jaret Wright P CLE Draft 1994 +4.9
Frank Francisco P TEX Trade 2003 +4.8
Michael Soroka P ATL Draft 2015 +4.3
Juan González OF CLE Free agency 2001 +4.3
Matt Williams 3B CLE Trade 1996 +4.1
Jack McDowell P CLE Free agency 1995 +4.0
Jody Gerut OF CLE Trade 2001 +3.9
Mike Jackson P CLE Free agency 1996 +3.9
Paul Sorrento 1B CLE Trade 1992 +3.9
John Thomson P TEX Free agency 2003 +3.9
Rod Barajas C TEX Free agency 2004 +3.8
Chris Young P TEX Trade 2004 +3.8
Paul Assenmacher P CLE Free agency 1995 +3.7
Ian Anderson P ATL Draft 2016 +3.6
Mark DeRosa 2B/3B TEX Free agency 2005 +3.6
Danys Báez P CLE Intl FA 1999 +3.5
Jason Davis P CLE Draft 1999 +3.5
Steve Karsay P CLE Trade 1997 +3.5
Shelby Miller P ATL Trade 2014 +3.4
David Dellucci OF TEX Free agency 2003 +3.4
Ryan Drese P TEX Trade 2002 +3.4
Kameron Loe P TEX Draft 2002 +3.2
Ervin Santana P ATL Free agency 2014 +3.1
Sean Newcomb P ATL Trade 2015 +2.8
Bob Wickman P CLE Trade 2000 +2.7
Taylor Teagarden C TEX Draft 2005 +2.6
Aaron Harang P ATL Free agency 2014 +2.5
Marty Cordova OF CLE Free agency 2000 +2.5
Dwight Gooden P CLE Free agency 1997 +2.4
Gerald Laird C TEX Trade 2002 +2.4
Kurt Suzuki C ATL Free agency 2017 +2.1
Tony Fernández SS CLE Free agency 1996 +2.1
William Contreras C ATL Intl FA 2015 +2.0
Jace Peterson 2B/3B ATL Trade 2014 +2.0
Ryan Drese P CLE Draft 1998 +2.0
Matt Lawton OF CLE Trade 2001 +2.0
Jack Morris P CLE Free agency 1994 +2.0
Kyle Wright P ATL Draft 2017 +1.9
Eddie Murray 1B CLE Free agency 1993 +1.9
Doug Brocail P TEX Free agency 2004 +1.9
Ron Mahay P TEX Free agency 2002 +1.8
Brian Shouse P TEX Free agency 2002 +1.8
David Riske P CLE Draft 1996 +1.7
Jason Grimsley P CLE Free agency 1993 +1.6
Mark Whiten OF CLE Free agency 1998 +1.6
Jim Johnson P ATL Free agency 2014 +1.5
Huascar Ynoa P ATL Trade 2017 +1.5
Jason Stanford P CLE Intl FA 1999 +1.5
R. A. Dickey P ATL Free agency 2016 +1.4
Charlie Culberson 3B/OF ATL Trade 2017 +1.3
Jason Grilli P ATL Free agency 2015 +1.3
Richie Sexson 1B CLE Draft 1993 +1.3
Dan Winkler P ATL Rule 5 2014 +1.2
Josh Bard C CLE Trade 2001 +1.2
Russell Branyan 1B/3B CLE Draft 1994 +1.0
Billy Traber P CLE Trade 2001 +1.0
Jamey Wright P TEX Free agency 2003 +1.0
Lane Adams OF ATL Free agency 2016 +0.9
Sam Freeman P ATL Free agency 2016 +0.9
Luiz Gohara P ATL Trade 2017 +0.9
Brian Anderson P CLE Trade 1996 +0.8
Chase d'Arnaud 3B/SS ATL Free agency 2015 +0.7
Mike Bielecki P CLE Free agency 1992 +0.7
Jacob Cruz OF CLE Trade 1998 +0.7
Sam Horn DH CLE Free agency 1993 +0.7
Rick Bauer P TEX Free agency 2005 +0.7
Ian Krol P ATL Trade 2015 +0.6
Kyle Muller P ATL Draft 2016 +0.6
Mallex Smith OF ATL Trade 2014 +0.6
Matt Wisler P ATL Trade 2015 +0.6
Jamie Brewington P CLE Free agency 1999 +0.6
Jeff Treadway 2B CLE Free agency 1992 +0.6
Esteban Germán 2B/3B TEX Free agency 2004 +0.6
Brad Wilkerson OF TEX Trade 2005 +0.6
Chris Haney P CLE Free agency 1999 +0.5
Joe Inglett 2B/OF CLE Draft 2000 +0.5
Edward Mujica P CLE Intl FA 2001 +0.5
Ted Power P CLE Free agency 1992 +0.5
Rich Rodriguez P CLE Free agency 2001 +0.5
Todd Greene C TEX Free agency 2002 +0.5
Ricardo Rodríguez P TEX Trade 2003 +0.5
Adonis García 3B ATL Trade 2015 +0.4
Jacob Webb P ATL Draft 2014 +0.4
Fernando Cabrera P CLE Draft 1999 +0.4
Álvaro Espinoza SS CLE Free agency 1992 +0.4
Rene Gonzales 2B/3B CLE Free agency 1994 +0.4
Steve Reed P CLE Trade 1998 +0.4
Carlos Almánzar P TEX Free agency 2003 +0.4
Jesse Biddle P ATL Trade 2016 +0.3
Pedro Ciriaco 3B/SS ATL Free agency 2014 +0.3
Brandon Snyder 1B/3B ATL Free agency 2015 +0.3
Mark Langston P CLE Free agency 1999 +0.3
Bob Ojeda P CLE Free agency 1992 +0.3
Jim Poole P CLE Free agency 1995 +0.3
Chan Ho Park P TEX Free agency 2002 +0.3
Rex Brothers P ATL Free agency 2017 +0.2
Casey Kelly P ATL Trade 2015 +0.2
Ian Thomas P ATL Draft 2014 +0.2
Jeromy Burnitz OF CLE Trade 1994 +0.2
Cameron Cairncross P CLE Trade 2000 +0.2
Billy Ripken 2B CLE Free agency 1995 +0.2
Mike Bacsik P TEX Free agency 2003 +0.2
Brandon Boggs OF TEX Draft 2004 +0.2
Aaron Fultz P TEX Free agency 2002 +0.2
Richard Hidalgo OF TEX Free agency 2004 +0.2
Michael Kirkman P TEX Draft 2005 +0.2
C. J. Nitkowski P TEX Free agency 2002 +0.2
Rubén Rivera OF TEX Free agency 2002 +0.2
Ismael Valdez P TEX Free agency 2002 +0.2
Eric Young 2B TEX Free agency 2004 +0.2
John Gant P ATL Trade 2015 +0.1
Luke Jackson P ATL Trade 2016 +0.1
Brandon McCarthy P ATL Trade 2017 +0.1
Andrew McKirahan P ATL Trade 2015 +0.1
Danny Santana OF ATL Trade 2017 +0.1
Jeremy Walker P ATL Draft 2016 +0.1
Bryse Wilson P ATL Draft 2016 +0.1
Mike Bacsik P CLE Draft 1996 +0.1
Pat Borders C CLE Free agency 1996 +0.1
Casey Candaele 2B/OF CLE Free agency 1995 +0.1
Sean DePaula P CLE Draft 1996 +0.1
Dave Elder P CLE Trade 2001 +0.1
Karim García OF CLE Free agency 2000 +0.1
Danny Graves P CLE Draft 1994 +0.1
Chris Nichting P CLE Free agency 1998 +0.1
Dave Roberts OF CLE Trade 1998 +0.1
Brian Tallet P CLE Draft 2000 +0.1
Matt Turner P CLE Trade 1994 +0.1
Mark Watson P CLE Trade 1998 +0.1
Wes Littleton P TEX Draft 2003 +0.1
Kevin Richardson C TEX Intl FA 2002 +0.1
Jed Bradley P ATL Trade 2016 +0.0
Jake Brigham P ATL Trade 2015 -0.0
Tucker Davidson P ATL Draft 2016 -0.0
Michael Kohn P ATL Free agency 2014 -0.0
Adam McCreery P ATL Trade 2016 +0.0
Alexi Ogando P ATL Free agency 2016 -0.0
Dustin Peterson OF ATL Trade 2014 -0.0
Michael Reed OF ATL Free agency 2017 -0.0
Robert Whalen P ATL Trade 2015 +0.0
Madison Younginer P ATL Trade 2016 +0.0
Kyle Denney P CLE Draft 1999 -0.0
Dave Hollins 3B CLE Free agency 2000 -0.0
Juan Lara P CLE Intl FA 1999 +0.0
Greg LaRocca 3B CLE Free agency 2001 +0.0
Torey Lovullo 2B CLE Free agency 1994 -0.0
Willie Martínez P CLE Intl FA 1995 +0.0
Lance Parrish C CLE Free agency 1993 +0.0
Geronimo Pena 2B CLE Free agency 1996 -0.0
Tony Peña C CLE Free agency 1994 +0.0
Ryan Thompson OF CLE Trade 1996 -0.0
Cliff Young P CLE Free agency 1993 +0.0
Joaquín Arias 3B TEX Trade 2004 +0.0
Mickey Callaway P TEX Free agency 2003 +0.0
Jason Hart OF TEX Trade 2002 +0.0
Eric Hurley P TEX Draft 2004 +0.0
Adam Hyzdu OF TEX Free agency 2005 -0.0
Travis Metcalf 3B TEX Draft 2004 -0.0
Dan Miceli P TEX Free agency 2002 +0.0
Tony Mounce P TEX Trade 2003 -0.0
Donnie Sadler 2B/OF TEX Free agency 2002 -0.0
Rudy Seánez P TEX Free agency 2002 +0.0
John Wasdin P TEX Free agency 2003 -0.0
Kolby Allard P ATL Draft 2015 -0.1
Jhoulys Chacín P ATL Free agency 2016 -0.1
David Freitas C ATL Trade 2017 -0.1
Jonny Gomes DH/OF ATL Free agency 2015 -0.1
Juan Jaime P ATL Trade 2014 -0.1
Micah Johnson 2B ATL Trade 2017 -0.1
Blake Lalli C/1B ATL Free agency 2016 -0.1
Matt Tuiasosopo OF ATL Free agency 2015 -0.1
Patrick Weigel P ATL Draft 2015 -0.1
Sean Casey 1B CLE Draft 1995 -0.1
Dave Maurer P CLE Free agency 2001 -0.1
Alan Newman P CLE Free agency 2000 -0.1
Joe Roa P CLE Trade 1994 -0.1
Dave Stevens P CLE Free agency 1999 -0.1
Chris Turner C CLE Free agency 1999 -0.1
Paul Wagner P CLE Free agency 1999 -0.1
Matt Young P CLE Free agency 1993 -0.1
Manny Alexander 2B/SS TEX Free agency 2004 -0.1
Danny Ardoin C TEX Free agency 2002 -0.1
Armando Galarraga P TEX Trade 2005 -0.1
Jeff Nelson P TEX Free agency 2004 -0.1
Josh Rupe P TEX Trade 2003 -0.1
Michael Tejera P TEX Free agency 2004 -0.1
Andrés Torres OF TEX Free agency 2004 -0.1
David Carpenter P ATL Free agency 2015 -0.2
Brandon Cunniff P ATL Trade 2015 -0.2
Joel De La Cruz P ATL Trade 2016 -0.2
Dana Eveland P ATL Free agency 2015 -0.2
Alex Jackson C ATL Trade 2016 -0.2
Sugar Ray Marimón P ATL Trade 2015 -0.2
Chad Sobotka P ATL Draft 2014 -0.2
Bruce Aven OF CLE Draft 1994 -0.2
Tom Martin P CLE Trade 1997 -0.2
Bob Milacki P CLE Free agency 1993 -0.2
Alvin Morman P CLE Trade 1997 -0.2
Jason Phillips P CLE Free agency 2001 -0.2
Jason Rakers P CLE Draft 1995 -0.2
Russ Swan P CLE Free agency 1994 -0.2
Ed Taubensee C CLE Trade 2000 -0.2
Bobby Witt P CLE Free agency 2000 -0.2
Sandy Alomar C TEX Free agency 2004 -0.2
Jason Conti OF TEX Free agency 2003 -0.2
Ryan Ludwick OF TEX Trade 2002 -0.2
Drew Meyer 2B TEX Draft 2002 -0.2
Ryan Snare P TEX Trade 2003 -0.2
Justin Thompson P TEX Free agency 2002 -0.2
Steve Woodard P TEX Free agency 2002 -0.2
Manny Banuelos P ATL Trade 2015 -0.3
Reid Brignac SS ATL Free agency 2015 -0.3
Roberto Hernández P ATL Free agency 2016 -0.3
Eric O'Flaherty P ATL Free agency 2016 -0.3
Héctor Olivera 3B ATL Trade 2015 -0.3
José Ramírez P ATL Trade 2015 -0.3
Rich DeLucia P CLE Free agency 1999 -0.3
Todd Dunwoody OF CLE Free agency 2001 -0.3
Alex Herrera P CLE Intl FA 1997 -0.3
Tim Laker C CLE Free agency 2000 -0.3
John McDonald SS CLE Draft 1996 -0.3
Matt Merullo C CLE Trade 1994 -0.3
Heath Murray P CLE Free agency 2001 -0.3
Chan Perry 1B/OF CLE Draft 1994 -0.3
Scott Radinsky P CLE Free agency 2001 -0.3
Kevin Seitzer 3B CLE Trade 1996 -0.3
Ron Villone P CLE Trade 1997 -0.3
Adrian Brown OF TEX Free agency 2005 -0.3
Ben Kozlowski P TEX Trade 2002 -0.3
Kevin Mahar OF TEX Intl FA 2004 -0.3
Doug Mathis P TEX Draft 2005 -0.3
Marshall McDougall 3B TEX Rule 5 2002 -0.3
Sam Narron P TEX Draft 2002 -0.3
Mario Ramos P TEX Trade 2002 -0.3
Víctor Santos P TEX Free agency 2002 -0.3
David Aardsma P ATL Free agency 2015 -0.4
Ryan Kelly P ATL Trade 2015 -0.4
Jason Motte P ATL Free agency 2017 -0.4
Eric Stults P ATL Free agency 2015 -0.4
Donnie Veal P ATL Free agency 2014 -0.4
Chris Withrow P ATL Trade 2015 -0.4
Paul Abbott P CLE Free agency 1993 -0.4
Rubén Amaro OF CLE Trade 1993 -0.4
Brady Anderson OF CLE Free agency 2001 -0.4
Roy Smith P CLE Trade 2001 -0.4
Earl Snyder 1B CLE Trade 2001 -0.4
Zach Sorensen 2B CLE Draft 1998 -0.4
Enrique Wilson 2B/3B/SS CLE Trade 1994 -0.4
Craig Worthington 3B CLE Free agency 1992 -0.4
Nick Bierbrodt P TEX Free agency 2004 -0.4
Brad Fullmer 1B/DH TEX Free agency 2003 -0.4
Matt Riley P TEX Trade 2005 -0.4
Travis Demeritte OF ATL Trade 2016 -0.5
Rio Ruiz 3B ATL Trade 2015 -0.5
Wil Cordero SS/OF CLE Free agency 1999 -0.5
Scott Leius 3B CLE Free agency 1996 -0.5
Kevin Mitchell OF CLE Free agency 1996 -0.5
Robert Ellis P TEX Free agency 2002 -0.5
Cristian Pache OF ATL Intl FA 2015 -0.6
Touki Toussaint P ATL Trade 2015 -0.6
Jeff Branson 2B/3B/SS CLE Trade 1997 -0.6
Jolbert Cabrera OF CLE Trade 1998 -0.6
Tim Drew P CLE Draft 1997 -0.7
Dave Winfield OF CLE Free agency 1995 -0.8
Ryan Christenson OF TEX Free agency 2003 -0.8
Germán Durán 2B/3B TEX Draft 2005 -0.8
Adrián González 1B TEX Trade 2003 -0.8
Aaron Blair P ATL Trade 2015 -0.9
Emilio Bonifácio 2B/OF ATL Free agency 2015 -0.9
A. J. Pierzynski C ATL Free agency 2015 -0.9
Matt Kemp OF ATL Trade 2016 -1.0
Brad Arnsberg P CLE Free agency 1992 -1.0
Chad Allen OF TEX Free agency 2003 -1.0
Bill Selby 2B/3B CLE Free agency 1999 -1.1
Tyrell Jenkins P ATL Trade 2014 -1.2
Brian Jordan OF TEX Free agency 2004 -1.2
Ricky Gutiérrez SS CLE Free agency 2001 -1.8

WAB = wins above what the team's payroll predicted (resource-controlled). WAR surplus = era-neutral value (WAR minus payroll in win-equivalents). Roster surplus $M = dollar value of WAR over cost. Build channels (realized fWAR): HG = home-grown via amateur draft / international signing; Trade = acquired minus surrendered (incl. purchases/waivers); FA = signed minus walked; R5 = Rule-5 / minor-league-draft pickups. Credit follows the acquisition year — home-grown to the regime at the player's draft/signing (not whoever was in the chair when he peaked), trade/FA/R5 to the GM who made the move. Players acquired as prospects before debuting (e.g. Smoltz, Bagwell; Rule-5 picks like Uggla) are counted as trade/R5, not home-grown. All are franchise-level outcomes during the stint, not solely attributable to one executive.